Posted by: David Giacalone | April 23, 2017

the at-risk west lawn of Riverside Park (with updates)

DSCF2858 update (Wed., 9 AM, May 3, 2017): Last night’s informational meeting on the Pumping Station at St. George’s demonstrated a strong, thoughtful and neighborly opposition. Today’s article in the Gazette by Brett Samuels left out some key points. For a detailed summary of the meeting, see our post strong, thoughtful opposition to pump station in the park” (May 3, 2017).

. . to share this posting, use the short URL:

NIOPsignF . . click for 3 printable “photo OpEds” to Save Our Park.

. . . Original Posting (with updates and links) . . 

Have we been taking the quiet beauty of the great West Lawn of Riverside Park for granted? I’ve recently heard it said that “no one uses that part of the Park” — the section between the old Pump House and Governor’s Lane. The statement was apparently being used to justify usurping most of the space, viewshed, and charm of the West Lawn for a giant new sewage pump station, modern and industrial in style, that would spread from near the old pump house to Governor’s Lane, as seen in the following rendering, which  comes from a 25-page Presentation to the Stockade Association Board of a proposed North Ferry Pump Station Project, given on March 1, 2017, by architect Frank Gilmore and CHA’s lead engineer Mike Miller:

. . click on rendering for larger image; full Presentation (pdf) . .

. . the SA Board and Officers never informed Members or residents of the Stockade of the size and location of the proposed Pumping Station until the last day of April, in the May Stockade Spy.

Not used? Not appreciated and valued?

To the contrary, we stroll by the West Lawn of Riverside Park on the Park’s one footpath when entering or leaving the Park from Washington Avenue or Governor’s Lane, and enjoy both its calmness when unoccupied and its activity when in use. We play bocce and frisbee on it, and run with our dogs and children. We sit on its benches to read, watch sunsets and crew sculls, tugboats and party boats on the Mohawk, and also heron on the Isle of the Cayugas or Scotia shore. We have picnics there, or quiet dates on a blanket. We occasionally see wedding parties and fashion models being photographed in front of Governor Yates’ brick wall, and the unique ornamental wall at the foot of what is now St. George’s parsonage.  We also very much enjoy a rare view of Stockade “backyards” — long, rolling or terraced yards of homes along Front Street.

. . above: view on Sunday, April 23, 2017 . .

 . . . .

. . .  

. . above: two renderings of the proposed pump station . .



I hope there will soon be a full, objective discussion of the Proposed Plan and alternatives to it (e.g. reuse the old pump house and its present lot, or a different location outside of the Park, perhaps out of the floodplain), and I hope it will be led by an energized and responsible Stockade Association. To the right is a thumbnail image of a collage with salient portions of the March 1, 2017 presentation; click on it for a larger version, and feel free to download it or the Project pdf. file for distribution.

red check. . for discussion of reasons to oppose a Pump Station project in Riverside Park, beyond the beauty-tranquilty-heritage-etc. displayed in this posting, and to decry the failure of the Stockade Association to inform its members and protect the Historic District and the Park, please see “Not In Our Park!“, at the website “snowmen at the gates” . .

This slide show has photos of the West Lawn, with views of it and from it, as well as people enjoying it.


This slideshow requires JavaScript.


. . share this post with the short URL:



. . a view from Scotia of the west end of Riverside Park (17Oct2013) . . 


SAPumpHouseLetter Note: Despite it Constitution and By-Laws, which commit the Stockade Association to protecting and preserving the residential nature of the Stockade district and to improve Riverside Park, the Stockade Association Board never notified the Association members or the neighborhood for two months after the March 1 presentation to them of the Project design. Moreover, in 2014, the Stockade Association president never put on the agenda or gave information to the Association and neighborhood about, the resolution before the City Council to place the Pumping Station in the Park rather than elsewhere, and rather than retrofitting the Old Pump House. When a motion by an SA member passed at the May 2014 general meeting, asking that a letter be sent to the Mayor concerning the Old Pump House and attempting to reuse it if technically feasible, the dismissive, minimalist, undated, informal note to the Right was sent to the Mayor and City Council. The matter was never again mentioned in the Stockade Spy or on the SA website in 2014.

 . . . 

above: [L] Loraine and Devin make his first snowman just outside the fence of 29 1/2 Front Street, in 2009; [R] Devin’s snowman is a lone sentinel outside the fence of 29 1/2 Front Street, echoing the famous, feckless snowmen at the gates of the Stockade the night of the 1690 Massacre.

dangersign Riverside Park is again under attack and at-risk. It is too special to saddle with an incongruous and inappropriate new development. As we have noted before, when working to protect Riverside Park:

  • 1998ParkResolution-text On January 26, 1998, a Resolution of the Schenectady City Council (including then-Council member Gary McCarthy) resolved, that Riverside Park “is recognized as a unique component of the [Stockade Historic] District and best serves residents and visitors as a quiet place to view the natural beauty of the Mohawk River.”  In addition, the Resolution stated that “to change its special nature would deprive visitors and disadvantage the homeowners who are the caretakers in this Historic District of national importance.”
  • With its combination of urban waterfront beauty and relative tranquility, Riverside Park was praised by the editor of Architect Forum as “probably the finest thing of its kind in America.” (Dec. 1961) 
  • rittnerdon-mug  Although he later unsuccessfully sought to have a 300-foot dock installed at Riverside Park for his Onrust replica boat, Don Rittner (former City and County Historian) was well aware of how special this Park is. He wrote in a report prepared in 2007 for the City Planning Department concerning a proposed Bike Trail, that “Riverside Park is valued as a unique component of the Stockade Historic District offering residents and visitors a relatively tranquil place to enjoy a magnificent view of the Mohawk River from the walking path and park benches.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: